The Challenge... A Tribute to Modern Art (1975)

102 mins | Documentary | 2 March 1975

Full page view
HISTORY

The film begins with the following statements: “Dedicated to the Artists who participated and to early Modern Masters whose genius created The Challenge” and “Filmed with the generous aid of the Ministry of Culture of France, the Cinemateque Francaise and the Art Museums of Europe and America.”
       End credits include the following: “With gratitude for the generous aid of D. H. Kahnweiler, Jean Leymarie, Aime Maeght, Henri Langlois, Peggy Guggenheim, Richard Johnson, John Russell, Suzi Gablik, David Thompson, Robert Hughes, and all who helped record The Challenge.” Also included is the acknowledgment: “Filmed with the gracious cooperation of: FRANCE: The Musee d’Arte Moderne, The Louvre, The Maeght Foundation, The Grande Palais, Matisse Chapel, Biennale de Paris – CNAC, Galerie Louise Leiris, Galerie France; ENGLAND: The Hayward Gallery, Marlborough, Fischer Galleries; ITALY: Vatican, Sistine Chapel; W. GERMANY: The Documenta, Kassel, Haus der Kunst, Munich; ISRAEL: The Bezalel Museum, Chagall Jerusalem Windows; USSR: Hermitage Museum; AMERICA: NYC, Museum of Modern Art, Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, Whitney Museum, The Chicago Picasso, Los Angeles County Museum of Art, Kansas City, Nelson-Atkins Museum, Washington D.C. National Gallery of Art; GALLERIES: NYC: Sidney Janis, Pace, Leo Castelli, Sotheby Parke Bernet, Knoedler. L.A., Ankrum; YOUNG ARTISTS: NYC, United Nations, UNIS International School, Art Students League-Will Barnet, L.A. Watts Towers Art Center.” Additional text in the end credits note: “Added scenes from films, Courtesy of: Hans Richter, Robert Snyder, Arnold Eagle, Paul Falkenberg, Hans Nemuth [sic], also NBC, NY; Pathé and O.R.T.F., Paris.” Additional acknowledgments state: “With the gratitude for the aid of: Gene Fowler, Jr., Lewis Jacobs, Sidney P. Solow, Art Cooper, Syd Cassyd, Evelyn Amerman; and special thanks to: Frederick Cains.”
       The ...

More Less

The film begins with the following statements: “Dedicated to the Artists who participated and to early Modern Masters whose genius created The Challenge” and “Filmed with the generous aid of the Ministry of Culture of France, the Cinemateque Francaise and the Art Museums of Europe and America.”
       End credits include the following: “With gratitude for the generous aid of D. H. Kahnweiler, Jean Leymarie, Aime Maeght, Henri Langlois, Peggy Guggenheim, Richard Johnson, John Russell, Suzi Gablik, David Thompson, Robert Hughes, and all who helped record The Challenge.” Also included is the acknowledgment: “Filmed with the gracious cooperation of: FRANCE: The Musee d’Arte Moderne, The Louvre, The Maeght Foundation, The Grande Palais, Matisse Chapel, Biennale de Paris – CNAC, Galerie Louise Leiris, Galerie France; ENGLAND: The Hayward Gallery, Marlborough, Fischer Galleries; ITALY: Vatican, Sistine Chapel; W. GERMANY: The Documenta, Kassel, Haus der Kunst, Munich; ISRAEL: The Bezalel Museum, Chagall Jerusalem Windows; USSR: Hermitage Museum; AMERICA: NYC, Museum of Modern Art, Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, Whitney Museum, The Chicago Picasso, Los Angeles County Museum of Art, Kansas City, Nelson-Atkins Museum, Washington D.C. National Gallery of Art; GALLERIES: NYC: Sidney Janis, Pace, Leo Castelli, Sotheby Parke Bernet, Knoedler. L.A., Ankrum; YOUNG ARTISTS: NYC, United Nations, UNIS International School, Art Students League-Will Barnet, L.A. Watts Towers Art Center.” Additional text in the end credits note: “Added scenes from films, Courtesy of: Hans Richter, Robert Snyder, Arnold Eagle, Paul Falkenberg, Hans Nemuth [sic], also NBC, NY; Pathé and O.R.T.F., Paris.” Additional acknowledgments state: “With the gratitude for the aid of: Gene Fowler, Jr., Lewis Jacobs, Sidney P. Solow, Art Cooper, Syd Cassyd, Evelyn Amerman; and special thanks to: Frederick Cains.”
       The name of photographer Hans Namuth was misspelled “Nemuth” in the acknowledgments.
       As noted in his 17 Feb 1999 NYT obituary, documentary filmmaker Herbert Kline began his career with a 1937 documentary about the Spanish Civil War, Heart of Spain, made for the then newly-established Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC). The following year, he created another film about the conflict in Spain directed by photographer Henri Cartier-Bresson (credited as Henri Cartier), Return to Life (1938, see entry). At the cusp of WWII, Kline stayed in Europe despite his Jewish origins and entered German-occupied Czechoslovakia, pretending to be a Nazi supporter. There, he filmed Nazi rallies as evidence of the party’s influence and released the footage as Crisis (1939, see entry). The same year, he documented Germany’s invasion of Poland and the film was exhibited in theaters as Lights Out in Europe (1940, see entry). Upon Kline’s return to the U.S., he made another documentary, The Forgotten Village (1941, see entry) and a narrative feature film, My Father’s House (1947, see entry), which was regarded as “one of the first films to document the Holocaust” and the first picture to be shot entirely in Palestine, before the establishment of Israel. However, Kline’s leftist political views brought him to the attention of the House Committee on Un-American Activities (HUAC) during the 1950s, and he was blacklisted. He remained inactive as a filmmaker until 1973, when he released a documentary about Mexican muralists Diego Rivera and David Alfaro Siqueiros, Walls of Fire (see entry), which was nominated for an Academy Award.
       With the success of Walls of Fire, Kline began working on The Challenge… A Tribute to Modern Art “without studio or network backing,” as noted in publicity materials in AMPAS library files. In response to questions about the inspiration of the documentary, Kline stated, “One day it occurred to me, what if cameras and sound had existed in the Renaissance to record Michelangelo… or what if someone could have filmed Manet, Cezanne, Van Gogh, Gauguin, Monet and Renoir as pioneers of modern art?” Realizing that most people did not have exposure to artists, their process of creation, or the art they produced, Kline decided to make art more widely accessible through the documentary, providing “deep insight into the origins of modern art.”
       According to publicity materials and a 23 Jan 1975 DV article, the film took three years and six months to complete, with principal photography starting 2 Apr 1971 at the Louvre Museum in Paris, France, and ending 10 Jul 1974 at the Los Angeles Museum of Art’s Rodin Sculpture Garden in CA. Kline was assisted by French director Jean Renoir, the son of Impressionist Pierre-Auguste Renoir, who provided Kline entry into French museums and artist studios. DV noted that Kline also persuaded artists to perform on film by presenting the documentary as “a lasting memorial to their talents” and by pledging ten percent of the film’s profits to the “UNICEF Art Fund” and another ten percent “to needy artists… determined by museums which cooperated… in the making of the picture.” In addition to footage filmed by Kline in Europe and the U.S., twenty percent the documentary was composed of previously unreleased film from the French national archives, as well as personal collections. According to Kline, the documentary was financed entirely by private investors, and with major contributions from Sidney Solow, the head of the film processing company Consolidated Film Industries.
       The Challenge… A Tribute to Modern Art screened throughout Mar 1975 at venues including the USA Film Festival in Dallas, TX, and Los Angeles theaters for Academy Award consideration. The film was presented in two parts, separated by a short intermission. A 4 Mar 1975 HR review noted that Kline was distributing the film himself, and he was planning to adapt the picture into “two one-hour television specials.” The 19 Mar 1975 LAHExam review added that a book about the making of the documentary was scheduled for publication through Skira. However, neither the release of the television program nor the book could be verified. On 18 Jun 1976, HR announced that New Line Cinema had acquired “exclusive distribution rights” with the intension of marketing the picture theatrically “as a fundraising device to specialized cultural organizations.” A 15 Sep 1976 Var review of a screening at the Deauville American Film Festival in France listed the film under the title The Challenge of Greatness.
       The film was nominated for an Academy Award in the category Documentary (Feature).

Less

GEOGRAPHIC LOCATIONS
SOURCE CITATIONS
SOURCE
DATE
PAGE
Daily Variety
23 Jan 1975
---
Hollywood Reporter
4 Mar 1975
p. 5, 11
Hollywood Reporter
18 Jun 1976
---
LAHExam
19 Mar 1975
Section B, p. 4
New York Times
17 Feb 1999
---
Variety
15 Sep 1976
p. 17
CAST
PRODUCTION CREDITS
NAME
PARENT COMPANY
PRODUCTION TEXTS
World View Productions
in association with The Challenge Group
A Film by Herbert Kline
DISTRIBUTION COMPANY
NAME
CREDITED AS
CREDIT
DIRECTORS
Asst dir/Aide
Asst dir/Aide
Asst dir/Aide
Asst dir/Aide
Asst dir/Aide
Asst dir/Aide
PRODUCERS
Co-prod
WRITERS
Commentary wrt by
PHOTOGRAPHY
and
Photog
and
Photog
and
Photog
FILM EDITOR
MUSIC
Orig mus
Mus ed
Orch cond
Violin
Percussion
Mouth harmonica
Clarinet
SOUND
Sd ed
VISUAL EFFECTS
Titles, opt & processing
Hollywood
PRODUCTION MISC
Prod consultant
Prod assoc, Scr
Prod assoc, Art
Prod assoc, Art
Prod assoc, Management
Prod assoc, Management
Cam, sd, ed staff, Europe
Cam, sd, ed staff, Europe
Cam, sd, ed staff, Europe
Cam, sd, ed staff, Europe
Cam, sd, ed staff, Europe
Cam, sd, ed staff, America
Cam, sd, ed staff, America
Cam, sd, ed staff, America
Cam, sd, ed staff, America
Cam, sd, ed staff, Elec
Equip
Paris
Consultant
DETAILS
Alternate Titles:
Herbert Kline's The Challenge: A Tribute to Modern Art
The Challenge of Greatness
Release Date:
2 March 1975
Premiere Information:
Los Angeles opening: 2 Mar 1975
Production Date:
2 Apr 1971--10 Jul 1974
Physical Properties:
Sound
Color
Eastman Kodak
gauge
35mm
Widescreen/ratio
1.33:1
Duration(in mins):
102
Country:
United States
Language:
English
SYNOPSIS

Paul Cézanne’s “Tulips in a Vase” sells at auction for $1.4 million. At the Musée d'Art Moderne de la Ville in Paris, France, Orson Welles wonders what it would be like to see the world through the eyes of Pablo Picasso and poses the question, “What is modern art?” He reflects that Picasso was not a revolutionary, but rather inspired by artists before him, such as Cézanne and his predecessors, the Impressionists. Art historian Pierre Schneider explains that Cézanne transformed art by making his brush strokes visible, thereby emphasizing the role of the artist in creating a painting’s illusion, or “window” to a fantasized world. According to Schneider, Picasso and Henri Matisse represented the “gateway” between Cézanne and modern art. Cubism followed, breaking the mold of traditional composition and turning the canvas into a surface with its own merits. Signifying this break with tradition, the Louvre Museum in Paris temporarily displaced Leonardo da Vinci’s “Mona Lisa” to make space for Picasso’s work. Also in Paris, Jewish-Russian painter Marc Chagall transformed the logic of Cubism into the irrational, emotional realm of Surrealism. In Rome, Italy, Chagall’s contemporary, Giorgio de Chirico, used classical techniques to represent “a tragedy of serenity” depicting subconscious fantasies. Back at the Musée d'Art Moderne, Schneider describes the work of Umberto Boccioni and his colleagues, who wanted art to transcend still lifes and convey the physical motion of real life; hence, Futurism was born. In Munich, Germany, Hitler once denounced modern art, as it was influenced by “non-Aryan” cultures throughout the world, including African tribal masks and Japanese woodcuts. While European modern artists fought for recognition, ...

More Less

Paul Cézanne’s “Tulips in a Vase” sells at auction for $1.4 million. At the Musée d'Art Moderne de la Ville in Paris, France, Orson Welles wonders what it would be like to see the world through the eyes of Pablo Picasso and poses the question, “What is modern art?” He reflects that Picasso was not a revolutionary, but rather inspired by artists before him, such as Cézanne and his predecessors, the Impressionists. Art historian Pierre Schneider explains that Cézanne transformed art by making his brush strokes visible, thereby emphasizing the role of the artist in creating a painting’s illusion, or “window” to a fantasized world. According to Schneider, Picasso and Henri Matisse represented the “gateway” between Cézanne and modern art. Cubism followed, breaking the mold of traditional composition and turning the canvas into a surface with its own merits. Signifying this break with tradition, the Louvre Museum in Paris temporarily displaced Leonardo da Vinci’s “Mona Lisa” to make space for Picasso’s work. Also in Paris, Jewish-Russian painter Marc Chagall transformed the logic of Cubism into the irrational, emotional realm of Surrealism. In Rome, Italy, Chagall’s contemporary, Giorgio de Chirico, used classical techniques to represent “a tragedy of serenity” depicting subconscious fantasies. Back at the Musée d'Art Moderne, Schneider describes the work of Umberto Boccioni and his colleagues, who wanted art to transcend still lifes and convey the physical motion of real life; hence, Futurism was born. In Munich, Germany, Hitler once denounced modern art, as it was influenced by “non-Aryan” cultures throughout the world, including African tribal masks and Japanese woodcuts. While European modern artists fought for recognition, many Americans embraced new artistic movements with enthusiasm, including writer Getrude Stein, photographer Alfred Stieglitz, as well as the Rockefellers and the Guggenheims, among others. At the Museum of Modern Art in New York City, Matisse, Ernst Kirchner, Hans Hoffmann, René Magritte, Joan Miró, and other modernists influence young artists. American Alexander Calder creates mobiles that transform sculptures into light, kinetic structures that compliment the space surrounding them. At his studio in Connecticut, Hans Richter assembles a collage from paper scraps while describing the Dada movement, which embraced the element of chance in art making. In Venice, Italy, Peggy Guggenheim explains that her collection is a historical “survey of all non-realistic movements in art, beginning with Cubism.” She notes that she would display such artwork at her gallery in London, England, and when it failed to sell, she purchased the best pieces as a conciliatory gesture to the artist. Catalan artist Salvador Dalí marked a variation in the Modernist movement, as he used traditional academic techniques to depict fantasy. At his studio, Dalí dips a squid into a vat of ink, then transforms the amorphous print into the portrait of a woman. In New York City, the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum displays the work of Jean Dubuffet and Paul Klee, who base their work on primitive imagery. Abstract expressionists, such as Piet Mondrian, eliminate figurative representations of reality altogether. Historian Pierre Schneider explains that after WWII, artists such as Jackson Pollock and Pierre Soulages based the subject of their artwork on the artistic gestures of the painter. At his studio, Soulages drags a brush, saturated with black paint, against the surface of a canvas stretched on the floor, then apologizes that he cannot paint in front of a camera. Chinese abstract expressionist Zao Wou-Ki explains that the Modernist movement transcends cultural boundaries. While Jackson Pollack’s “action painting” expressed vitality, Willem de Kooning, interviewed in his studio, says he “paints fast to keep the glimpse” into his subconscious alive. As Robert Motherwell paints, he says that he aims to be “economical” with his brush strokes to portray “an instant moment of contemplation.” He tells art critic Robert Hughes that his series, “Elegy to the Spanish Republic,” is “not political, but my private insistence that a terrible death happened that should not be forgot.” In archival footage, Picasso explains that his masterpiece “Guernica,” which expressed the tragedy of war, as well as his other paintings, “are memoirs, like notes one writes to oneself.” Back at Musée d'Art Moderne, Orson Welles describes the work of Fernand Léger, who used his paintings to capture the power of machinery and human bodies. Similarly, Alberto Giacometti and Francis Bacon created figurative images to express unconscious experiences. Andre Masson, whose “automatic technique” inspired Pollock and others, argues: “Surrealism is everywhere.” At the French studio of Romanian sculptor Constantin Brâncuși, Pierre Schneider explains that the artist “took the revolutionary step of freeing sculpture from its century-old submission to subject matter,” using figurative constructions to depict “the essence behind the appearance.” Another illustrious sculptor, Jacques Lipchitz, who was known for translating Cubism into sculptural forms, wishes to live longer than one hundred years; however, he died shortly after the interview. In England, sculptor Henry Moore says that he finds it impossible to imagine life without art, and Anthony Caro works with assistants to dismantle a sculpture for an upcoming exhibit in New York City. In the U.S., Louise Nevelson constructs Cubist “sculpture houses” in her studio with moveable parts so others can rearrange them. She tells critic Robert Hughes that as a woman, her work is different than art produced by men because she is “primitive,” using simple tools “to get what I want.” In Rome, Italy, Giacomo Manzù designs religious art, even though he is a Communist. Elsewhere in Italy, at the Carrara quarry where Michelangelo sourced his marble, Japanese-American sculptor Isamu Noguchi prepares for an upcoming exhibit at the Whitney Museum in New York City, claiming that sculpture is about dialog, not material value. In Paris, the Israeli kinetic artist Yaacov Agam uses motion and light to create sculptural art objects and the founder of France’s Cinémathèque museum, Henri Langlois, argues that Agam’s paintings are evocative of film, as they represent the intersection of time and imagery. English painter Bridget Riley is also inspired by geometry and optical illusion. She tells critic David Thompson that wavelengths of color swell and contract in response to each other, much like musical notes. In her studio near Paris, Portuguese painter Vieira da Silva explains that she does not see the world through traditional perspectives, as she is more interested in expressing aspects of time. New York City African American artist Romare Bearden says that he tries to “X-ray” his subjects to show what is going on behind the surface. Marcel Duchamp sought to undermine artistic pretentions with “readymades,” presenting everyday objects as art, or “anti-art.” His pioneering work into Conceptual art inspired Pop artists in the 1960s, including Andy Warhol, Jasper Johns, and Robert Rauschenberg, who detoured from Abstract Expressionists by embracing graphic images, such as advertisements. At his New York City studio, Roy Lichtenstein projects comic strips and graphic work by other artists to create abstractions. The Venice Biennale features work by young artists who seek reactions from their audience. Art critic Pierre Schneider explains that modern art is a question rather than an answer, with no traditional criteria by which to judge its merits. Artist George Segal says that his sculptural work borders on abstraction and realism, using figurative sculptures to represent fatastical “places that I can enter.” Public figures such as Yoko Ono and John Lennon exploit their celebrity to promote the perception of art as a conceptual process rather than a physical object. At the Documenta exhibition in Kassel, Germany, Joseph Beuys claims “thinking is sculpture” and Claus Oldenberg displays a “mouse museum.” Back in his New York City apartment, Oldenberg tells Robert Hughes that his “three-way plug” electrical outlet inspired artwork. At the National Gallery in Washington, D.C., U.S. government officials and socialites mingle with U.S.S.R. dignitaries at an exhibition of Russian modern art collections, proving that art traverses social and political divides. Walking past masterpieces at Musée d'Art Moderne, Orson Welles evokes the words of Matisse, saying, “The characteristic of modern art is to participate in our life.” Welles notes that there will never be an end to innovation in art; he challenges people to view artistic movements with appreciation and an open mind.

Less

Legend
Viewed by AFI
Partially Viewed
Offscreen Credit
Name Occurs Before Title
AFI Life Achievement Award

TOP SEARCHES

Blue Movie

The 25 Jun 1969 Var review noted that Blue Movie was shot in Sep 1968 in New York City. Along with several other contemporary sources, ... >>

The Best Years of Our Lives

The working titles of the film were Glory for Me and Home Again . In the opening credits, actor Fredric March's name is spelled correctly, but ... >>

Psycho

Actor Vaughn Taylor's surname is misspelled "Tayler" in the onscreen credits. Several Jun and Jul 1959 HR news items erroneously refer to the film as Psyche. ... >>

Jeopardy

The working title of this film was Riptide . According to a HR news item, portions of the film were shot on location in Dana ... >>

Harold and Maude

During the opening credits for the film, Bud Cort, as the character "Harold Chasen," sets the stage for a mock suicide. As director Hal Ashby's credit appears, Harold jumps ... >>

The American Film Institute is grateful to Sir Paul Getty KBE and the Sir Paul Getty KBE Estate for their dedication to the art of the moving image and their support for the AFI Catalog of Feature Films and without whose support AFI would not have been able to achieve this historical landmark in this epic scholarly endeavor.